Why Non-Muslim Smashes Ridhuan Tee Abdullah..

Here is why the indian community and non muslim slams Ridhuan Tee Abdullah. His racist remarks towards the indian community was unreasonable without even a single blink to the current government which was giving their bless to the movie itself.

The problem occurs when you speak without knowing the truth behind the scene. 

The article wrote by Ustaz Ridhuan Tee Abdulah. Taken from Sinar Harian.

Majlis Madrasah India Muslim Malaysia (MIM) memberi maklumat kepada saya mengenai kontroversi filem Vishwaroopam, yang dihentikan penayangannya buat sementara waktu oleh Kementerian Dalam Negeri (KDN), ekoran banyak adegan menghina agama Islam. Malangnya, parti politik India komponen Barisan Nasional (BN), mendesak mahukan filem ini terus ditayangkan kerana pada mereka ia hanya lakonan. Jahil sungguh mereka dalam memahami budaya masyarakat Islam.

You have written this on 18 feb 2013. But on 19 feb 2013, KDN has lifted the ban of the film. You can refer below links to recofirm it.
 
http://www.sinarharian.com.my/kolumnis/ridhuan-tee-abdullah/kesabaran-umat-islam-ada-had-1.132091


http://www.thesundaily.my/news/616439

The temporary ban imposed on controversial Tamil blockbuster Vishwaroopam was lifted today.

In a statement, the Home Ministry said the movie, directed and produced by south Indian movie superstar Kamal Haasan, will be allowed to screen in local cinemas as the special panel consisting of the National Film Censorship Board and the Islamic Development Department (Jakim) had looked into the movie from the religious and safety aspects.

“Two discussion and review sessions were held with Jakim to reassess the content of the movie.

“Jakim, through its director general has agreed to allow the movie to be shown in the cinemas as it is satisfied with the censorship done by the Film Censorship Board.

“Based on the reviews and opinions of all parties, the Ministry has agreed that Vishwaroopam will be allowed to be screened but on condition that the film distributors abide by the decision taken by the Film Censorship Board on the additional (scenes) from the film to be censored,” said the Film Censorship Board chairman Datuk Raja Azahar Raja Abdul Manap.

And Ridhuan Tee writes

Berikut adalah ringkasan penghinaan yang sengaja dilakukan terhadap agama Islam yang mulia ini. Pertama, umat Islam digambarkan sebagai pengganas. Kedua, Kitab suci al-Quran katakan sebagai rujukan pengganas. Ketiga, pakaian wanita berhijab/purdah tempat menyimpan senjata api dan bom. Keempat, ayat-ayat al-Quran dibaca bagi memulakan aktiviti jahat. Kelima, pengikut Taliban dikaitkan dengan penyembelihan manusia dan keenam, agama Islam digambarkan sebagai agama yang tidak berperikemanusiaan.

Apa tujuan filem ini sebenar? Bagaimana filem ini boleh terlepas? Walaupun KDN telah menarik penayangannya buat sementara waktu, itu bukan bermakna kita perlu berdiam diri dan berbaik sangka dengan mengatakan ia tidak disengajakan? Bagaimana jika kita melakukannya terhadap agama lain?

Difahamkan sebanyak 16 penyuntingan akan dibuat sebelum tayangan semula dilakukan. Siapakah yang menyunting filem ini sebelum ditayangkan? Orang Islam atau orang bukan Islam? Apakah patut mereka dilepaskan begitu sahaja?

The answer to your question as above. Refer to the statement issued by KDN. JAKIM is the responsible body to review and bar certain scenes from the film before they could re-release to the local cinema. Re-release because it was approved back then before they banned it temporary for short review and now they approved it, AGAIN. Put the blame to JAKIM instead to the indian community. Jakim has failed to explain why we must stop the film. Not piggie-blinded blames the non muslim.

First, if we have something to say regarding the movie, we better put a valid argument related to the topic. Bragging about other stuff, dragging unrelated issues only showing that we are not enough credible to discredit the movie through facts. 

Me, myself didn't agree with the movie. Singapore, the country which malays always labelled as racist also banned the movie. Means something is not right about the movie. The movie must be so insensitive toward the muslim and that's why many countries banned the movie, even in their homeland the movie became controversy. After several discussion and went going few editing process the movie then release in India.

If you can't accept the movie you have to list down your argument instead of writing below statement.  

Pernahkah kita bersungut ketika perayaan Thaipusam? Seminggu sebelum perayaan, seluruh kawasan sekitar Batu Caves sesak. Kenderaan diparkir sesuka hati. Lautan manusia satu warna berhimpun, seolah-olah tidak ada warna lain lagi di negara ini.

Hari ini pergilah ke mana sahaja. Jika dahulu, rumah ibadat dan patung-patung tidak banyak kelihatan meriah. Kalau adanya pun agak suram dan tidak nampak tombolnya. Tetapi selepas PRU 12, keadaan jauh berubah. Mereka mendapat peruntukan sana sini, pusat dan negeri. Rumah ibadat kecil menjadi besar, tombol rendah menjadi tinggi dan berwarna-warni.

Apa yang saya lihat, kita sudah memberi segala-galanya bagi menagih simpati dan undi. Negara ini tidak ada lagi identiti. Agenda Islam dan Melayu entah ke mana. Saya amat yakin jika BN menang sekalipun dalam PRU 13 ini, keadaan tidak ada bezanya dengan apa berlaku hari ini. Kita akan terus menjaga hati orang lain daripada hati sendiri.

Persoalan saya, apakah agenda kita hanya untuk pilihan raya? Kita tidak bertegas dalam melaksanakan agenda negara. Tidak cukup dengan kontroversi filem tersebut, amat meloyakan apabila semua parti komponen BN meramalkan mereka akan menang banyak kerusi yang ditandingi dalam PRU 13. Hairannya, kerusi yang diramalkan menang dan mahukan itu adalah kerusi yang ditandingi kawasan majoriti Melayu.

Mereka mendesak diberikan tambahan kerusi. Jika benar-benar ikhlas, pergilah menawarkan diri bertanding di kawasan majoriti ultra kiasu (Cina). Mintalah kerusi sebanyak mana pun. Tetapi beri laluan kepada orang Islam bertanding di kawasan majoriti Melayu.

Saya cadangkan agar PRU 13, jika kita mahukan sangat orang India bertanding di kawasan majoriti Melayu, carilah kalangan India Muslim seperti KIMMA dan MIM, tetapi bukan mereka yang tidak Islam. Orang Melayu tidak teragak untuk memangkah mereka, tetapi apakah mereka memangkah kita apabila laluan diberikan? Apakah mereka akan menjaga dan menghormati sensitiviti agama Islam. Kontroversi filem Vishwaroopam jelas menunjukkan mereka langsung tidak sensitif terhadap agama rasmi negara ini.

None of your argument were pointing to the related issues. We are talking about the movie and you are bragging about the indian community in malaysia? What's the connection actually? I didn't see anything.

You didn't help the muslim community to translate the real reason why we must refuse and say no to the movie. You only help to make the situation change, from bad to worse. The indian community became more confused. And angry.

Nevermind then. When a muslim insulted islam, through their action, especially the way of their dressing, in the movie, none of them trying to fix the thing, even Ustaz Ridhuan Tee has shut down his mouth. But when non muslims questioning why we banned the film? What was going wrong? Need a futher explaination, then it's wrong.

I believed we can discuss the matter nicely with indian community without insulting each other. I also believed, the indian community can accept our argument as long as we provided the facts, not a wild accusation nor being racist to prevent racist. When a racist talks about how he hates racism while himself is practising it, then he must be a damm stupid.  

Forget to mention this. Jakim is an islamic body and home minister is a muslim too. Ask them why they allowed such movie airing at the cinema in malaysia. :)